All three Barstool Sports Advisors finished the NFL regular season with a losing record of picks.
- Dave Portnoy: 45-52-1 (Mortals 7-10)
- Stu Feiner: 40-43-1 (Mortals 7-0)
- Big Cat: 59-67-2 (Mortals 7-9)
Feiner finished with the best winning percentage (48.2%) and Big Cat (46.8%) barely edged out Portnoy (46.4%).
Every week, we highlight Barstool Sports Advisors analysis and you can choose to follow or fade when betting on the NFL at PA sports betting apps.
Barstool Sports Advisors NFL Week 18 picks
New England Patriots vs. Miami Dolphins pick
Dave Portnoy
The pick: Patriots -6.5
“The Patriots don’t owe me anything this year. I laid huge wood on them on the Over 7.5 win total. I had them at Over 9 win total and I have them to win the division at +330. If you’re not going to get the No. 1 seed, which they aren’t, they are actually better on the road. They are probably going to play the Bengals or the Bills and I’m hoping round 3 with Buffalo and the winner of that probably wins the Super Bowl. I still wish they won the division but I am still sold on this team.”
Stu
The pick: Under 39.5
“Traditionally, Miami destroys New England in Miami, it’s a nightmare. New England, right now, could they beat the Chiefs on the road, yes. Could they beat the Titans, yes. I think this game is a low-scoring game. Under, under, under.”
Big Cat
The pick: Dolphins +6.5
“The Dolphins are 8-0 versus teams where the starting quarterback has an “o” in their last name. If Dave moves to Nashville there will be a story that says your alt-right favorite heroes Ben Shapiro, Dave Portnoy and Tomi Lahren all move to Nashville.”
Final score: Dolphins 33, Patriots 24
New Orleans Saints vs. Atlanta Falcons pick
Dave
The pick: Falcons+4.5
“These are one of the Dave Portnoy brain stats. You expect the Saints because they have something to play before but it almost never works like that. The team has nothing to play for plays free and easy and wins. I think the Falcons win this game.”
Stu
The pick: Under 39.5
“I’m going to go Under here, too. This will be a very tight game. This is a gotta win playoff game for New Orleans. How do they win? With defense. Matty Ice is melting in to the ground. Biggest choke artist ever.”
Big Cat
The pick: Saints -4.5. Under 39.5
“I disagree with Dave. (Tommy Stats says the Under is 7-1 Taysom Hill’s last 8 starts).”
Final score: Saints 30, Falcons 20
Seattle Seahawks vs. Arizona Cardinals pick
Dave
The pick: Over 48, Cardinals -6.5
“I have the Cardinals at 13-1 to win the NFC. I’m not convinced with them. This is as wide open the NFL has been in a while, nothing would surprise me. I think this is going to be a close game.”
Stu
The pick: Under 48
“The Cardinals have an amazing defense. It’s the whole ball of wax. I really like the Under.”
Big Cat
The pick: Over 48
“I hate Russel Wilson now and I think he is completely fake. I love the Over. The Seahawks are just playing for stats now.”
Final score: Seahawks 38, Cardinals 30
San Francisco 49ers vs. Los Angeles Rams pick
Dave
The pick: 49ers +5.5
“Jalen Ramsey punching guys. They are wild and crazy guys….I don’t want them on my team.”
Stu
The pick: 49ers +5.5
“I’m going to take the 49ers here. I don’t know why. I think the Niners are underrated. They are nasty and if they can get it together they can ruin everybody’s season.”
Big Cat
The pick: 49ers +5.5
“I’m back on my boy crush Kyle Shanahan. He also owns Sean McVay.”
Final score: 49ers 27, Rams 24
Los Angeles Chargers vs. Los Vegas Raiders pick
Dave
The pick: Over 49.5
“I have no idea. I was ready to make a bundle on the Raiders until the Ruggs incident. The Chargers, I was pretty right with them and have never been sold on them. I’m always wrong about the Raiders. I’m just going to take the Over.”
Stu
The pick: No pick
Big Cat
The pick: Raiders +3
“The Raiders have had everything go wrong this year. I’m going to say a team of destiny and the destiny is making it to the playoffs and losing in the first round. They are winning outright.”
Final score: Raiders 35, Chargers 32
Barstool Sports Advisors Week 18 “mortal locks”
Dave
The pick: Patriots -6.5
“We missed the playoffs last year, it’s good to be back in the big dance.”
Final score: Dolphins 33, Patriots 24
Stu
The pick: Ravens -3
“I think the Ravens are going to make a run in the playoffs and stun a lot of playoffs. Anything can happen…”
Final score: Steelers 16, Ravens 13
Big Cat
The pick: Chargers vs. Raiders Over 48.5
“Who doesn’t want that to be an Over. I think the Chargers are going to go for it on every fourth down.
Final score:
Final score: Raiders 35, Chargers 32
Barstool Sports Advisors NFL record
Barstool Sports Advisors Week 18 records
- Big Cat: 6-1
- Portnoy: 3-3
- Feiner: 1-4
Barstool Advisors season record
(Sunday picks only included in overall record)
- Portnoy: 45-52-1 (Mortals 7-10)
- Stu Feiner: 40-43-1 (Mortals 7-9)
- Big Cat: 59-67-2 (Mortals 7-9)
Bet with Barstool promos
Barstool Sportsbook PA has a number of “bet with Barstool” promos.”
Big Cat Can’t Lose Parlay: Colts, Bills and Buccaneers all to win; Over 41.5 points in Chargers vs. Raiders boosted from -140 to +225. (lost)
NFL Wild Card odds
Lead image Barstool Sports YouTube
