As promised, Big Cat and Stu Feiner returned for the NFL playoffs (Dave Portnoy is in Miami). Jersey Jerry is filled in for Portnoy on the show. Portnoy did make picks for Wild Card weekend and shared them on his social media.
Stu Feiner went 6-0 (including his mortal lock) during wild card weekend.
Barstool Sports Advisors Wild Card records
- Stu Feiner: 5-0, Mortal lock won
- Big Cat: 5-5, Mortal lock lost
- Jersey Jerry: 1-5, Mortal lock lost
All three Barstool Sports Advisors finished the NFL regular season with a losing record of picks.
- Dave Portnoy: 45-52-1 (Mortals 7-10)
- Stu Feiner: 40-43-1 (Mortals 7-0)
- Big Cat: 59-67-2 (Mortals 7-9)
Feiner finished with the best winning percentage (48.2%) and Big Cat (46.8%) barely edged out Portnoy (46.4%).
“People were making fun of our records. We are the greatest handicapped handicappers our there. We make our picks on Wednesday sometimes Tuesday. COVID, injuries, line movement…I never know what I like on Wendesday but I get here and give you people winners 48% of the time.”
Every week, we highlight Barstool Sports Advisors analysis and you can choose to follow or fade when betting on the NFL at PA sports betting apps.
Dave Portnoy Wild Card picks
Portnoy tweeted on Friday “Here it is. My 6 team Wildcard parlay. All you got to do is bet 10 bucks and if it wins we will tack on a free 1000. Here are the winners. You don’t even have to watch.”
- Cardinals +4
- Chiefs – 12.5
- 49ers +3.5
- Eagles +9
- Patriots +4
- Bengals -5.5
Portnoy’s wild card record: 3-3
Barstool Sports Advisors Wild Card picks
Las Vegas Raiders vs. Cincinnati Bengals pick
Jersey Jerry
The pick: Raiders +5
“I can’t bet against the Raiders after what they did for me.”
Stu
The pick: Bengals -5
“This game is on Saturday where there’s 150 college basketball games where I have been murdering people, big time winning. I don’t think, in any lifetime, the Raiders can stay there with the Bengals. Between Burrow and Chase, unguardable, unstoppable. You gotta lay this number all day.”
Big Cat
The pick: Over 49
“I hate this spot because the Raiders had an emotional game. No one has ever sent a text message about a Bengals playoff win. I don’t like this game.”
Final score: Bengals 26, Raiders 19
New England Patriots vs. Buffalo Bills pick
Jersey Jerry
The pick: Patriots +4.5
“This is outta respect for Dave, I love the Bills in this spot, but I gotta pick the Patriots for Dave.”
Stu
The pick: Over 44.5
“Obviously, revenge is written all over here. Bils would love to humiliate the Patriots. This is extremely hard. On the side selection, I’m going to hold off. Everyone is betting Under, I think there will less than hundred points but more than 46.”
Big Cat
The pick: Patriots +4.5, Under 44.5
“I like the Patriots +4.5 just because of the familiarity of these teams. It’s going to be a field goal game.”
Final score: Bills 47, Patriots 17
Philadelphia Eagles vs. Tampa Bay Buccaneers
Jersey Jerry
The pick: Over 49
Stu
The pick: Under 49
“The Tampa Bay Buccaneers won the Super Bowl last year, not because of Tom Brady, but because of their defense. They made Pat Mahomes look like a child. Shaq Barrett and company in the playoffs bring the D. Philly will not be able to run the ball. Jalen Hurts is probably going to die. This is a lock under.”
Big Cat
The pick: Buccaneers -9, Over 49, Buccaneers team total over 28.5
“I love this game and know the score of this game, Buccaneers 34, Eagles 20. This is an Over and Bucs play. Bucs are going to demolish the Eagles. I like the Eagles and everything Nick Sirianni has done. If you look under the hood, they have beaten shitty teams.”
Final score: Buccaneers 31, Eagles 15
Dallas Cowboys vs. San Francisco 49ers pick
Jersey Jerry
The pick: 49ers +3
“Remember my friend who was dying from a heart attack. George Kittle sent him a video and a few days later he was out of the hospital. 49ers by a billion.”
Stu
The pick: Under 50.5
“Niners are playing well. You don’t want to play them because their defense is good enough to shut you down. On the offensive side of the ball they are suspect. Cowboys are much better than the Niners. I think the defense for the Cowboys will show up. 49ers defense has to show up. There will be about 7-8 sacks in this game.”
Big Cat
The pick: 49ers +3
“I love this game because of the nostalgia. The Cowboys are going to murder the Niners. I have the Coyboys 10/1 to win the Super Bowl for $10k. I’m an idiot.”
Final score: 49ers 23, Cowboys 17
Pittsburgh Steelers vs. Kansas City Chiefs pick
Jersey Jerry
The pick: Steelers +500
“When you talk about the Steelers, and talk about Jersey Jerry, this is my mortal lock. The Steelers are back. Big Ben is back. Give me the Steelers moneyline. That’s my mortal lock.”
Stu
The pick: Over 46
“Let’s go Over with Big Ben”
Big Cat
The pick: Over 46
Final score: Chiefs 42, Steelers 21
Arizona Cardinals vs. Los Angeles Rams pick
Jersey Jerry
The pick: Cardinals +4
“Because of my hate for Aaron Donald, he’s a fraud. T.J. Watt’s the best defensive player in football.”
Stu
The pick: No pick
Big Cat
The pick: Cardinals +4
Final score: Rams 34, Cardinals 11
Barstool Sports Advisors Wild Card “mortal locks”
Jersey Jerry
The pick: Steelers ML +500
Final score: Chiefs 42, Steelers 21
Stu
The pick: Bengals -5.5
Final score: Bengals 26, Raiders 19
Big Cat
The pick: Cardinals vs. Rams Over 49.5
“Simply an end of the weekend, have a beer, watch the Over.”
Final score: Rams 34, Cardinals 11
Barstool Sports Advisors NFL record
Barstool Advisors season record
(Sunday picks only included in overall record)
- Portnoy: 45-52-1 (Mortals 7-10)
- Stu Feiner: 40-43-1 (Mortals 7-9)
- Big Cat: 59-67-2 (Mortals 7-9)
Bet with Barstool promos
Barstool Sportsbook PA has a number of “bet with Barstool” promos.”
Advisors Mortal Lock Parlay: Over 49.5 in Cardinals vs. Rams; Bengals -4.5; Steelers +12.5 boosted from +570 to +670. (lost)
NFL Wild Card odds
Lead image Reed Hoffmann/AP
